Stop starring! Boy am I glad these are just chocolate coated peanut butter eyeballs. If this had been a real starring incident, I am sure a fight will ensue soon.
These eyeballs are made by combining peanut butter, butter and icing sugar together. They are very sweet. The original recipe did not have this but I added a salted peanut in the centre to give it a crunch and a tinge of saltiness.
Preparation is easy, coating them is not. It is quite a finicky task and I gave up after coating only this many eyeballs. The rest I just covered it entirely in white chocolate. So those became blind eyeballs with no irises. Gross!